Rate the Cougars: Fan Consensus Grades

SpiffCoug

MVP: Legend Glasker5.5/10 (C-)

"Survive and Advance."

Wins are wins. The more wins BYU piles up the higher the chances of making the College Football Playoffs are. The Cougars' regular season schedule had two big tests and 10 other tests of various difficulty. So far BYU is 1/1 on the big tests and 6 of 7 on the other tests. Now comes the 2nd big test, which is now the biggest and most difficult of the season. A road game against rival Utah. BYU's efforts the last two games since defeating Notre Dame (currently #3) have been less than stellar. That will need to change if BYU wants to solidify those playoff chances. A win should also go a long way in getting BYU back to the Big XII Championship Game.

Keegs

MVP: Jayven Williams6/10 (C)

"Did just enough to win."

hawkwing

MVP: Kyler Kasper6/10 (C)

"Another win that was way too close"

This was an ugly win. But an ugly win still counts as a win in the record book. It's hard to pick anyone who was MVP. Bear had some nice throws, but also the pick and struggled to run the ball. Kasper had some nice catches, but also the drop. Legend had the nice long catch, but was otherwise pretty quiet. Same with Lyons. I would love to see BYU just dominate a game from start to finish. Not sure I ever will.