I have a really hard time with diversity initiatives, because I have seen them blow up badly by putting unqualified people in places they shouldn't be. No one will say so, but they're generally quota-based and stem from fear of lacking diversity. That is usually translated into "we have to be diverse to be successful." Wrong. We have to be talented. Let's ID the best talent, and pick those who will be a good fit is a good model. There are diverse places to find talent and fit.
With that, here's my opinion on what's going at at BYUs professional schools.
I personally know 3 of the 6 alums on the MSM page.
I know for a fact they had options other than BYU at more prestigious universities. I consider myself friends with 2 of them and have mentored all 3. Each was offered financial aid by BYU to come and enroll in the program, however, each more than qualified for their spot considering their GMATs, work experience, and undergrad GPA. So I can tell you straight up that they weren't brought in just for their diversity, though one friend used the line "BYU's getting more diverse one brotha at time!"
Like it or not, what the MSM (and JRCLS) are doing is responding to their customers: Recruiters. Several large customers have stopped doing busines with BYU due to lack of diversity. Translation: recruiters stopped hiring BYU students because they can't reach thier own diversity goals with BYU students.
Whether those goals are right or not is debatable. However, BYU is producing a product, and if customers won't buy, then some tweaking will happen. Even at the subsidized tuition, BYU can't tell enrollees that they may or may not have a job when they graduate because there aren't enough diverse candidates to attract top notch recruiters.
It's kind of like "green" initiatives. Some of my customers are in the mining industry and if I can't help them be "green neighbors", they will look elsewhere for services I offer. What's not relevant is whether the "green initiatives" matter.
On a related note, I have also been told by a Dean of the MSM that after Prop 8 several major companies elected to stop hiring from BYU. He asked me if mine might do the same (we didn't).
Not trying to hijack the thread, just offering my insights.