Here's another argument I love...
"Who has BYU played? Nobody really. At least SDSU has beat a team like Gonzaga." This was said even just a few weeks ago. I just love it when people base their perceptions off of preseason rankings/predictions and never update their "file" once the season starts. Now BYU has beat the following ranked teams or teams receiving votes:
#6/6 SDSU
#15/16 Arizona
#21/17 Utah State
#30/23 Saint Mary's
39/33 UCLA
#40/41 UNLV (x2)
#42/NR CSU
#43/36 UTEP
...not to mention all the conference leaders as previously mentioned. Yet people still call out schedule into question. I love when people use/cite the RPI only when it supports their touting of a "big 6" team but reference its "flaws" when the "mid-majors" somehow wind up with a high number.
Meanwhile the MWC goobers a.k.a BYU haters who were using the same argument to diminish BYU's schedule were touting SDSU's schedule as being much tougher; the same SDSU who has only beaten the aforementioned Saint Mary's, UNLV and CSU teams.