Archived Topic

It's not the recruits - and it's not a coincidence

by Italics · 10/17/2010

Advertisement
I
Italics
Guys, I keep seeing some people talk about how awful our team and players are. I keep seeing some people talk about how overrated Chambers is, how much Jacobsen has given up. how disappointing Heaps has been, etc. etc. etc.



Guys... I realize that recruits are not always all they're hyped up to be... but usually they are. That's why the teams that have the money and get the recruits tend to have the best teams. That's just how it goes.



It is NOT a coincidence that all of the top talent we get usually ends up failing to meet expectations. Does anyone really think that when talented players come to BYU they just start sucking? Other teams do great things with their talent, but it seems we often fail to.



Heck - putting things in perspective... I begin to wonder if the 2-3 loss seasons we've had the last few years should have been considered disappointments? Unga, Hall, Tonga, Collie, and Pitta... those are five guys right there in the NFL, some of them even starting (Unga's injury prevents us from knowing what would've happened with him). That's FIVE NFL talented guys we've had playing for us... would other schools have done better with such talent? It's worth pondering...



In case this has all gone over your heads, the point I'm trying to get across is that - as poor as some of our players have looked at times - it's obvious that the issue is with coaching. This is not a "fire Bronco" thread - in fact, I am very impressed with what he's done with our defense. This is more aimed at our "offense"...
M
Mars


What past games has our offense underachieved in?



Perhaps 14 points against Oklahoma, but it's hard to complain there.

28 points in a 26-point loss to Florida State.

7 points in a 31-point loss to TCU.

24 points in a 5-point win over New Mexico last year.

28 points at Washington in a 1-point win.

21 points against New Mexico.

7 points in a 25-point loss to TCU.

24 points in a 24-point loss to Utah.

20 points at home against Arizona.

17 points in a 10-point loss to UCLA.

24 points against UNLV.

17 points against Utah.

13 points in a 3-point loss at Arizona.

24 points at Colorado State.



Anae has had a lot of really good games, but he has also had a lot of really good talent playing against Bottom 20 scrubs.



He is better at gaining yards than he is at scoring points. He tends to under-use the run, and completely abandon it when losing. He likes to throw on 3rd and short and run on 3rd and long, throw near our own end zone and when we're trying to run out the clock, running the ball instead of kneeling it when ahead with time running out near the end of a half. He seems to consistently play senior players over better underclassmen, and doesn't like the ride the hot hand, not giving more touches to whoever is playing best in a game. He is absolutely terrible at half-time changes to faulty gameplans. He ignores many good plays and schemes for vanilla looks and predictable playcalling.



I wouldn't mind a fresh look in 2011. The team seems to need it. This is Div. I football. Stagnation is death.
O
OhYePoorFools
The problem is our coaching and we need new blood ASAP. Our program is dying on the vine.
This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.