Lawboy wrote:
Wondering if he is gone already, and his schollie for 2010 was given to DeQuan Everett? To land that kid, we had to be able to offer a full, and it had to come from somewhere, right? And I know we are short on them right now, so Te'o leaving might have been a good thing.
No, the DeQuann commit came nearly right after 2010 LOI day as I recall. Malosi's walking out on BYU if true is much more recent. What this could do is provide the scholarship needed for Jacob Murphy if that situation is still as volatile as rumored to be. Message boards have a way of making it seem like these kids left after getting pissed off or feeling like they have been mistreated but I bet more often than not, it's a mutual agreement between the coaches and players that the kid would be better off somewhere else. That said, I really do think there is mounds of evidence to suggest that players are better off sticking it out with the original school they signed with than transferring part way through their eligibility. I can think of very few who got playing time at their new school and even fewer who made it to the NFL. Malosi will still have to sit out a year and will be playing without a scholarship now, at least initially, and there's still no guarantee that he won't be riding the pine for the rainbow warriors too. I really don't get what is with these kids who think that if they don't start in year one that it's time to move on. I really don't get why you would leave a scholarship at one place to go somewhere else when you are a borderline D1 prospect anyway. I'd take the great and free education BYU offers and enjoy practice and hope that I eventually got to see the field some.
Jacob Bower, Cade Cooper, Sam Doman, Gary Nagy, Matt Ah You, Isley Filiaga are just a handful of guys who transfered out and who's careers never amounted to anything else. We'll see what kind of impact guys like Jerry Bruner, Brannon Brooks, and G Pittman make.
Then there are names like Brandon Doman, Steve Young who bided their time deep on the depth chart and eventually got their chance, and became entrenched in Cougar lore.