This World Cup has been bittersweet for me. I've been following the USMNT for a while now, such that I can name the strengths and weaknesses of every player on the 23-man roster (and the initial 30-man camp roster). Looking at the roster, this team had the potential make the quarters or even the semis, but it wasn't to be. The poor central defense play and lack of finishing touch did the US in.
This World Cup reinforces to me the idea that the difference between a being a semifinalist and a knocked out in group stage is razor thin. At the World Cup, so many teams pack it in on defense, such that one team can dominate the run of play and still lose (Switzerland over Spain or Slovakia over Germany). It's what teams do on their few good attempts on goal proves to be the difference in getting 3, 1, or 0 points from a match. Ghana were gifted two defensive errors and scored on both. The USA was unable to convert its similar opportunities.
Looking at the 8 quarter-finalists, every one of them has looked mediocre in this tournament. Germany lost to Slovakia. Brazil beat N Korea by 1 goal. Spain lost to the Swiss. Argentina struggled with Nigeria. The Dutch haven't been lighting up the scoreboard. Labeling the USA as mediocre is fair, though perhaps in a World Cup where no single team has stood out as elite, mediocrity leaves the USA in some pretty good company.