QB Strategies

Several folks have said they want the best guy on the field (or variants of that: the guy who will give us the best chance of winning, etc.)

Question:

You're the OC. Do you want to start

1. the guy most likely to give you the best season record (a static strategy). [You make a decision before the Washington game and stick to it the rest of the season, barring injury.]

2. the guy most likely to give you the best record the rest of the season (an adaptive strategy) [You're allowed to switch only once during the season]

3. the guy who can give you the best chance of winning the next game (a dynamic strategy) [You take it "one game at a time"]



As we argue about the name of the guy for each scenario, I wonder what people think the best strategy is. (We can also ignore or not continuity effects that switching might have).

I say camp 1. Pick a QB and stick with them. That would/could even include sticking with them if they struggle for a game or two - especially if you wind up picking Nelson. If you chose Nelson, it is my contention that you have to RS Heaps. Otherwise, switching to him after several games is wasting his talent. If you were going to go with him middle of the season it is my opinion that it would have been better served to have started with him.