I am not impressed

I am very unimpressed with BYU coaching. I find it amazing we gave this coach an extension. The only justification I can think of for that is that consistency generally makes for a more successful program, therefore searching for a new coach just puts that back that much further. But Sitaki is so out coached so often, and even on the games we win, his decisions do not seem to be the deciding factor.



We just lost a bowl game from not coaching to our strengths. We out weighed Hawaii by 60 pounds at least, and still can't move the ball consistently on the ground. We don't make first half adjustments when they are needed. The announcer was explaining how poor we were coached in both the first half and the second half, and I mostly agreed with him.



I am very disappointed. I luv FB. I want to play well. But this coach doesn't have the necessary knowledge to coach D1.

Since Kalani is our coach the next four years, he must fire Tuiaki to give me any semblance of hope he can improve.

SpiffCoug wrote:

Since Kalani is our coach the next four years, he must fire Tuiaki to give me any semblance of hope he can improve.

When you drop 8, get four sacks, but still give up almost 500 yards passing, something is seriously seriously messed up.

Hawaii looks like a fun team to cheer for...

sage wrote:

I am very unimpressed with BYU coaching. I find it amazing we gave this coach an extension. The only justification I can think of for that is that consistency generally makes for a more successful program, therefore searching for a new coach just puts that back that much further. But Sitaki is so out coached so often, and even on the games we win, his decisions do not seem to be the deciding factor.



We just lost a bowl game from not coaching to our strengths. We out weighed Hawaii by 60 pounds at least, and still can't move the ball consistently on the ground. We don't make first half adjustments when they are needed. The announcer was explaining how poor we were coached in both the first half and the second half, and I mostly agreed with him.



I am very disappointed. I luv FB. I want to play well. But this coach doesn't have the necessary knowledge to coach D1.

The worst part is that in the second half we WERE moving the ball on the ground with good results, and then on 3rd and 2 with a chance to end the game, we throw. Not to put the whole game on that one play, but it was an accurate representation of the general mismanagement of the game.

It's amazing to me how many people on Twitter are defending Kalani. There are some pretty vocal Kalani supporters. Guy is barely above .500. If only my professional performance was based on how nice of a guy I am.

Gunk wrote:

It's amazing to me how many people on Twitter are defending Kalani. There are some pretty vocal Kalani supporters. Guy is barely above .500. If only my professional performance was based on how nice of a guy I am.

Those people make me sick. And couldn't really care less about whether we win or not. The only Kalani holdout at this point should be his mom.

I've said since the Utah state game that I was hoping that Baylor Romney was going to start the rest of the year. I really feel if he had BYU would have won out. Unfortunately, Kalani got his extension the second he got his 6th win this year and now he doesn't feel that urgency to win so he went back to his "guy" in Wilson. I understand that the defense gave up a ton of points against hawaii but IMO, Wilson and his turnovers were the difference.

BroncoBot wrote:

Hawaii looks like a fun team to cheer for...

I never cheer for a Nick Rolovich coached teams. I have too many bad memories of what he did to BYU in 2001.

SpiffCoug wrote:

Hawaii looks like a fun team to cheer for...

I never cheer for a Nick Rolovich coached teams. I have too many bad memories of what he did to BYU in 2001.

72-45. I'm glad I was in Ukraine for that one.

KingCoug wrote:

It's amazing to me how many people on Twitter are defending Kalani. There are some pretty vocal Kalani supporters. Guy is barely above .500. If only my professional performance was based on how nice of a guy I am.

Those people make me sick. And couldn't really care less about whether we win or not. The only Kalani holdout at this point should be his mom.

Haha!



It's funny to me too because they act like there is some secret side or identity that us critics don't know about and if only we did than we would all be Kalani fans too. Okay...so share this amazing secret side that would make putting up with Kalani and a slightly above average BYU team enjoyable.



I'd rather have a coach that knows what they are doing and produces a good product on the field than one that doesn't know what they are doing but is a "nice" guy.