I realize that pointing out any positive thing that BYU does in a loss to Utah just won't go over well with BYU fans, but speaking for myself I felt encouraged after this Utah loss. We did so many things uncharacteristically well in that game.
From 2011-2017, our offense has been on the field with the lead vs. Utah for a total of 3 plays. The fact that we not only led, but dominated for an entire half against Utah is something we haven't seen in a long time.
Utah is a P5 team that will finish with a winning record. Look at what we have recently done vs. P5 teams with a winning record. In the last 5 seasons we have played 13 games vs. P5 teams that have finished with a winning record. We never had the lead in 8 of those games. We were shut out in 2 of them. We have won only one (Wisconsin) and never had more than a 7 point lead in that game. We had the lead in the 4 other games. The largest lead was a 10 point lead against UCLA in 2015 before the Utah game this year.
Utah has won 9 games this year. Since Lavell took over we are 3-36-1 all time vs. P5 teams that won 9 games or more. Our wins came against Miami in '90, Kansas St. in the Cotton Bowl, and ASU in '97. That's the list. In 26 out of those 40 games we couldn't score 20 points so much as get a 20 point lead.
The first half against Utah was the best half BYU has ever played against a 9 win or better P5 (BCS or Major independent) team. I can't fault Holmoe for citing that as the highlight of the season.