From a life-long and academic/career perspective, Taysom should go to either Michigan or UVA. Both are TREMENDOUS academic institutions. To have a BYU degree with a UM or UVA master's degree makes an exceptional resume.
From a football perspective:
- BYU has a good schedule. Two games in NFL stadiums and a bunch of games on ABC and ESPN/FOX. UCLA, Michigan St., Utah, Arizona, Mississippi St. - plus your home state rival in Boise St. Poinsettia Bowl at the end of the year is anti-climactic - and there will only be ONE at large spot for the NY6 in 2016 - because the Peach and Fiesta host the CFP.
- At Michigan, you play in the Big House EIGHT times - pretty sweet. Michigan starts off with FIVE games in the Big House. FIVE. Hawaii, UCF, Colorado (pretty easy lineup to break in as the new QB), then Penn St.! and WIsconsin! Road games at Rutgers, Michigan St., Iowa, and Ohio St.! That's a pretty sweet schedule against QUALITY competition down the stretch. Do well and play in the B1G championship and the Rose Bowl - may be even the CFP! Even a good but not great year you get to play in the Citrus Bowl on New Year's Day against an SEC opponent!
- UVA has a potentially easier schedule than BYU. UVA doesn't play FSU or Clemson in 2016. They play at Oregon, but then get UConn, Central Michigan, and FCS Richmond OOC. Then, the ACC Coastal Division with Wake Forest and Louisville as the cross-division opponents. If you do well, there's a chance to play Clemson or FSU in Charlotte for the ACC title - and a chance at the CFP or Orange Bowl.
Personally, I think Taysom heads to Michigan - and it's almost certain that Taysom leaves.