Archived Topic

BYU's place in the football universe

by KingCoug · 9/26/2015

Advertisement
K
KingCoug
SCENARIO #1 - CONTINUED INDEPENDENCE



This is probably what it will be for the foreseeable future. Holmoe always hoping for that phone call from Bob Bowlsby from the Big 12. Playing with the Big Boys is fun...until it's not. I, as much as anyone, want to compete on that stage. But it seems like, every year, reality slaps me in the face and I go back to what I call "strategic scheduling."



What would that include?



I would have 9 core games that we play every year that included regional, other independent, and academy opponents:



Utah

Utah State

Weber State

Boise State

Hawaii

Notre Dame

Army

Navy

Air Force



You could fill the other 3 games any way you want, depending on how ambitious you're feeling.









SCENARIO #2 - BIG 12 INVITE



Baylor, Iowa State, Kansas , Kansas State, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, TCU, Texas Texas Tech, West Virginia



This is obviously assuming we do get that call from the Big 12 at some point. Looking at the current Big 12 line up, where do we fit in? I'm guessing we'd be somewhere in the middle of the pack most years. We'd be a P5 team, and have the chance to go places if we won our conference, but how often would that be?









SCENARIO #3 - RETURN TO THE MOUNTAIN WEST



Air Force, Boise State, Colorado State, Fresno State, Hawaii, Nevada, New Mexico, San Diego State, San Jose State, UNLV, Utah State, Wyoming



My Cougar pride cringes when I even ponder this. But looking at the current MWC line up below, I wonder if we are closer to that conference than any P5 conference. I do think we would be at or near the top most years, competing mainly with Boise State for #1. And a trip to a NY6 bowl game would be ironically more likely. But a playoff appearance would never happen until it expanded to 8 teams. And even then, maybe not.
G
Guest
If BYU drops to the MWC they should just drop to Div 1aa. Recruiting will completely die in the MWC because LDS kids can go to Utah, Stanford, UCLA, or a dozen other P5 schools. BYU's only hope, since they aren't in a P5 conference right now is to have strong 9+ win years every year so they can continue to compete against p5 teams in recruiting.
K
KingCoug
hawkwing wrote:
If BYU drops to the MWC they should just drop to Div 1aa. Recruiting will completely die in the MWC because LDS kids can go to Utah, Stanford, UCLA, or a dozen other P5 schools. BYU's only hope, since they aren't in a P5 conference right now is to have strong 9+ win years every year so they can continue to compete against p5 teams in recruiting.


I see what you're saying. And 9+ wins a year is where I guess strategic scheduling comes into play.
This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.