Archived Topic

Ranking the Bowl Games

by byutx · 12/22/2009

Advertisement
B
byutx
This is likely my last Christmas break of my life, so my Christmas present to myself is that I'm going to watch every bowl game, or as much as possible if there are too many games at the same time. So, I'm going to one-up the sports writers who ranked the games based mostly on bias and guessing, I'm going to rank them based on the games themselves. All that matters to me is that the game involves good and entertaining football. Thus, a game like the BSU/Oregon game this season would rate much lower than a game like the Wyoming/Fresno New Mexico Bowl.



1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno in double overtime thriller. Will probably stay in the top 5 all season.

2. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green in a shoot out with a great finish, not as good a game as the NM Bowl. Also, before Idaho, the WAC and WestIdahoCoug slap themselves on the back for this one, please note that this was the MAC's 14th straight bowl loss. Hasn't won a game since 2006

3. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina by two with a FG at almost the very end. Relatively entertaining and close throughout.

4. Music City Bowl-Clemson wins in a close one over Kentucky. Some awesome plays by Spiller et al and a well executed fake punt. Pretty fun to watch.

5. Sun Bowl-Oklahoma over Stanford with a second half come back and some great defensive play

6. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio in what started out as crap, but ended up pretty good in the 2nd half.

7. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss with some pretty awesome offensive play by QB Dasher. Was close up to the last few minutes. If you hate our bowl tie-ins, it could be worse. Playing a Sunbelt (or a Conf USA) team would make me down right suicidal. Probably a mid-level game.

8. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC in the rain. I guess only USC is the only PAC 10 team that was interested in their bowl to this point. Close until the 4th quarter.

9. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple in a slow comeback. Not a very exciting bowl game.

10. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State. Enough craziness to make it more than the average blow out. Probably a bottom 10 game, though.

11. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal. More interesting than St. Petersburg Bowl, not as entertaining as the LV Bowl.

12. Armed Forces Bowl-AFA over Houston with some amazing defensive, offensive and special teams play (especially the FG at the end of the 2nd quarter and the kickoff return for a TD in the 3rd)

13. Insight.com Bowl-Iowa State over Minn. in an extremely boring game with a somewhat misleading close score.

14. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami-Hurricanes made it closer in the end than it actually was. More proof that not having a real QB taking the snaps is a bad idea generally.

15. Texas Bowl-Navy blows out Missouri. Not pretty for Mizzou, fun for non-AQ fans everywhere.

16. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm by 24, despite being outgained by them by 105 yards. This might have been the worst 60 minutes of football I've seen since the BSU/Oregon or Utah/Oregon games. 4 third down conversions in the first half and a bunch of turnovers and special teams snafus just made this awful. Is this really both teams' 13th game?

17. Chick-fil-A Bowl-VaTech over TN in a total snooze fest.

18. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida in a major turd of a game. Outcome never really in question. Both these teams suck. Most likely a bottom 5 game.

19. Holiday Bowl-Nebraska blanks Arizona. I fell asleep a few times, thanks to the DVR I was able to rewind it.

20. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada. Most likely the worst of all 34 bowls. Awesome watching the WAC suck.
M
Magnus Ver Magnusson
I love your idea. I will be able to see a handful of bowl games but often find myself sucked in when an exciting one comes on. I'll stay tuned to see your analysis.
B
byutx
Magnus Ver Magnusson wrote:
I love your idea. I will be able to see a handful of bowl games but often find myself sucked in when an exciting one comes on. I'll stay tuned to see your analysis.

Thanks. I would be honored to have a former World's Strongest Man contribute to this thread!
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno in double overtime thriller. Will probably stay in the top 5 all season.

2. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss with some pretty awesome offensive play by QB Dasher. Was close up to the last few minutes. If you hate our bowl tie-ins, it could be worse. Playing a Sunbelt (or a Conf USA) team would make me down right suicidal. Probably a mid-level game.

3. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State. Enough craziness to make it more than the average blow out. Probably a bottom 10 game, though.

4. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida in a major turd of a game. Outcome never really in question. Both these teams suck. Most likely a bottom 5 game.
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno in double overtime thriller. Will probably stay in the top 5 all season.

2. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss with some pretty awesome offensive play by QB Dasher. Was close up to the last few minutes. If you hate our bowl tie-ins, it could be worse. Playing a Sunbelt (or a Conf USA) team would make me down right suicidal. Probably a mid-level game.

3. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State. Enough craziness to make it more than the average blow out. Probably a bottom 10 game, though.

4. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal. More interesting than 5, not as entertaining as the LV Bowl.

5. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida in a major turd of a game. Outcome never really in question. Both these teams suck. Most likely a bottom 5 game.

6. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada. Most likely the worst of all 34 bowls. Awesome watching the WAC suck.
Advertisement
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno

2. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

3. Music City Bowl-Clemson wins in a close one over Kentucky. Some awesome plays by Spiller et al and a well executed fake punt. Pretty fun to watch.

4. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio

5. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss.

6. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC in the rain.

7. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State.

8. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal.

9. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

10. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada.
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno

2. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

3. Music City Bowl-Clemson over Kentucky

4. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio

5. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss.

6. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC in the rain.

7. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple in a slow comeback. Not a very exciting bowl game.8. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State.

9. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal.

10. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm

11. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami-Hurricanes made it closer in the end than it actually was. More proof that not having a real QB taking the snaps is a bad idea generally.

12. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

13. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada.
B
byutx
I'll do 12/31's games later tonight.



1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno

2. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green in a shoot out with a great finish, not as good a game as the NM Bowl. Also, before Idaho, the WAC and WestIdahoCoug slap themselves on the back for this one, please note that this was the MAC's 14th straight bowl loss. Hasn't won a game since 2006

3. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

4. Music City Bowl-Clemson over Kentucky.

5. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio

6. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss

7. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC

8. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple

9. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State

10. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal

11. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami

12. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm

13. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

14. Holiday Bowl-Nebraska blanks Arizona. I fell asleep a few times, thanks to the DVR I was able to rewind it.

15. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada
M
Mars
byutx wrote:
2. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green in a shoot out with a great finish, not as good a game as the NM Bowl. Also, before Idaho, the WAC and WestIdahoCoug slap themselves on the back for this one, please note that this was the MAC's 14th straight bowl loss. Hasn't won a game since 2006

And here I picked CMU to beat Troy...
B
byutx
Mars wrote:
2. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green in a shoot out with a great finish, not as good a game as the NM Bowl. Also, before Idaho, the WAC and WestIdahoCoug slap themselves on the back for this one, please note that this was the MAC's 14th straight bowl loss. Hasn't won a game since 2006

And here I picked CMU to beat Troy...

Probably still a safe bet.
Advertisement
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno

2. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green

3. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

4. Music City Bowl-Clemson wins in a close one over Kentucky.

5. Sun Bowl-Oklahoma over Stanford with a second half come back and some great defensive play

6. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio

7. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss

8. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC

9. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple

10. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State

11. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal

12. Armed Forces Bowl-AFA over Houston with some amazing defensive, offensive and special teams play (especially the FG at the end of the 2nd quarter and the kickoff return for a TD in the 3rd)

13. Insight.com Bowl-Iowa State over Minn. in an extremely boring game with a somewhat misleading close score.

14. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami

15. Texas Bowl-Navy blows out Missouri. Not pretty for Mizzou, fun for non-AQ fans everywhere.

16. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm

17. Chick-fil-A Bowl-VaTech over TN in a total snooze fest.

18. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

19. Holiday Bowl-Nebraska blanks Arizona

20. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno



2. Outback-Auburn over Northwestern in an extremely exciting but multiply-interrupted finish that was enough to save an otherwise unremarkable game



3. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green

4. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

5. Music City Bowl-Clemson wins in a close one over Kentucky.

6. Sun Bowl-Oklahoma over Stanford

7. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio



8. Capital One Bowl-Penn St over LSU on a gross field in an even grosser game



9. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss

10. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC

11. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple



12. Gator Bowl-FSU over West Virginia in a game that yet again exposed the problem of running the spread without a passing threat. Relatively entertaining through much of the game.



13. Rose Bowl-Ohio St over Oregon in a pathetic showing of Oregon offense and defense against an extremely overrated, mediocre Ohio State. Poor execution, mistakes etc. made this game hard to watch. It was close enough that it stayed interesting until the 4th quarter.




14. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State

15. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal

16. Armed Forces Bowl-AFA over Houston

17. Insight.com Bowl-Iowa State over Min

18. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami

19. Texas Bowl-Navy blows out Missouri

20. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm

21. Chick-fil-A Bowl-VaTech over TN



22. Sugar Bowl-FL crushes pretender Cinci in what was somewhat entertaining, but for the wrong reasons. Cinci, playing against their first real top 15 team of the season, showed they are who I thought they were. Their play was a good example of "what not to do" on the football field.



23. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

24. Holiday Bowl-Nebraska blanks Arizona

25. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada
B
bball
I loved the Air Force (Armed Forces Bowl) and Navy (Texas Bowl)games. I just love seeing these "little" service academies sticking it to the big, bad boys. I thought the TT vs MSU game was a heck of a game.



I loved the gutsy call by the Idaho coach to just go for the two point conversion, and win the game. I loved seeing Arizona get humiliated by Nebraska, and the Pac-10 taking a dump, generally.



I loved seeing all the MWC teams just whuppin their opponents, great year for the Mountain West. I don't think anybody saw Wyoming winning their game, but I was impressed with them, they would not accept defeat.



I'm an emotional fan, that is I go with my heart, and the excitement of the game as it unfolds. I like seeing any SEC team lose, and any Big-10 team lose, and the Pac-10 lose. I like seeing the service academies outplay, and win against bigger, better opponents. I like seeing ESPN fumble around with trying to defend the "big football" schools as they are getting humiliated by Navy, AF, BYU, etc.
B
byutx
1. New Mexico Bowl-Wyoming over Fresno

2. Outback-Auburn over Northwestern

3. Humanitarian Bowl-Idaho over Bowling Green

4. Meineke Car Care Bowl-Pitt over North Carolina

5. Music City Bowl-Clemson over Kentucky

6. Sun Bowl-Oklahoma over Stanford



7. Liberty Bowl-Arkansas over ECarolina in an OT game that was pretty ugly. How does team win a bowl game without completing one 3rd down conversion? (AR was 0/14 in that stat) The answer, of course, is "by playing E. Carolina".



8. Little Caesar's Bowl-Marshall over Ohio

9. Capital One Bowl-Penn St over LSU

10. New Orleans Bowl-Mid Tennessee State over So. Miss



11. Alamo Bowl-Texas Tech over MSU in a relatively high scoring and entertaining game. I wish there was some way both TT and the Big Ten could've lost this game. I know who the real loser is, though: Adam James



12. Emerald Bowl-USC beats BC

13. Eagle Bank Bowl-UCLA over Temple

14. Gator Bowl-FSU over West Virginia

15. Rose Bowl-Ohio St over Oregon

16. LV Bowl-BYU rolls Oregon State

17. Poinsettia Bowl-Utah rips Cal

18. Armed Forces Bowl-AFA over Houston

19. Insight.com Bowl-Iowa State over Min

20. Champs Sports Bowl-Wisconsin over Miami

21. Texas Bowl-Navy blows out Missouri

22. Independence Bowl-UGA over aTm

23. Chick-fil-A Bowl VaTech over TN



24. Cotton Bowl-Ole Miss over Oklahoma State (more like Ole Miss given the win by the refs over Oklahoma state) Both teams played like crap. 12 Turnovers, 12 punts, 2 separate failures to score after 1st and goal and 2 missed field goals are just some of the lowlights.



25. Sugar Bowl-FL crushes pretender Cinci

26. St. Petersburg Bowl-Rutgers over Central Florida

27. Holiday Bowl-Nebraska blanks Arizona

28. Hawaii Bowl-SMU has their way with Nevada



29. Papajohns.com bowl-UCON over South Carolina in a crap game that would've been worst on this list, if not for the International Bowl



30. International Bowl-So. Fla over Northern Illinois. I've got nothing to say other than that this game sucked-if nobody in the US cares about this game, why do we think people in Canada will?
G
Guest
bball wrote:
I loved seeing all the MWC teams just whuppin their opponents, great year for the Mountain West. I don't think anybody saw Wyoming winning their game, but I was impressed with them, they would not accept defeat.


Check out my ESPN Bowl Challange entry. I saw them winning.
Advertisement
B
byutx
I don't have time right now to update this, so I'm going to wait until after the UT/AL game.
This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.