mormonrasta wrote:
mormonrasta wrote:
mormonrasta wrote:
What's Patterson talking about National Championships for? He isn't even voting his own team #1 right now.
But is he voting them #2?
I'm not sure that matters. If he believes his team is worthy to play for the national championship then he should vote in a manner that would give his team the best chance play for that championship. Any other vote, even a #2 vote, is shortchanging his team.
So, even if he honestly believes UF is #1, and honestly believes his team is #2, he should vote his team #1 despite instructions to vote candidly? I strongly disagree with suggesting that if he believes his team is #2 and deserving of a spot in the BCS champtionshp then he should lie in an attempt to make it happen.
The BCS championship game are for teams that think they are #1. That game is to determine the best team in the country not the 2nd best.
If Patterson thinks his team belongs in that game, he needs to act accordingly and vote his team number 1. By voting his team number 2 he is saying that he doesn't belong in that game and is not doing his team any favors. His first responsibility is to his team not the poll.
No, the BCS Championship game is for the two teams who a complex computer algorithm determines are #1 and #2 to play on the field so that one of the two polls awarding a national championship are then obligated to vote them #1.
As for your second point about responsibility, I hope my kids don't learn ethics from you. You never lie to get ahead. If Gary Patterson doesn't think his team is better than Florida, he should not dishonestly rank them #1 to try and get a shot at them. If the #1 ranking were the be-all-end-all, they wouldn't play the game--they would do the final BCS rankings and ship the trophy UPS. The BCS is about determining #1
and #2 so that those two teams can fight it out for a trophy.
The BCS Championship is about which teams are #1 and #2, and then let them fight it out for a trophy. No one has ever said that the best team always wins....hence the phrase "that's why we play the game." #2 is just as worthy to play that day as is #1---and you shouldn't have to lie to get there.