The most fun game for me is usually the next game almost regardkess of the opponent because I love to watch my team - starters and reserves alike - and can hardly wait for the action to start. The next game right now is The Utes which is phenominal - but the 2 week wait is killing me.
But since you are probably asking re games that already happened, recency, impact nationally for the team and individuals, storied opponents with us as underdogs, arrogance of opposing fans and players, etc., factor in. Complex.
Michigan - NC
Miami - Won the Heisman for Detmer
SMU - Amazing comeback for McMahon
Texas - Recency, Brand, Improbable, unusual way it happened
K-State - Capped 14-1 Season in 1st Jan 1 Bowl
Missouri - Miracle finish for Steve Young
UCLA - Blocked kick at the gun - improbable
A&M - Polite, but arrogant fans
Oklahoma - Memory of Barry Switzer
TCU - Road vs #15
ND - Brand
Some Utah games probably fit in up there, but they all kind of run together in my mind. But yeah - the clanked field goal, 4th and 7, Staley, Harline, Andrew George, Max Hall's rant, are all up there somewhere.
The night Riley Nelson saved the program from a 2nd consecutive Jake Heaps led loss is up there somewhere because of how down BYU was at the time and the implications of such a loss. Then BAM. Running. Throwing. OL pushing the pile forward. Too bad he did not have the body to sustain that.
Tons of other wins vs U, UCLA, UW, ASU, A, WSU, Ole Miss, and other BCS teams.
Some SDSU, AFA, and other conference dog fights were fun.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ] 
http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">