Cougarbib wrote:
And, yes - there is no love lost between Chow and BYU. Chow was run out of town by unrealistic BYU fans. IDK if he would have been a good HC. Y fans got Crowton instead. And now Bronco. And the whiny ones will never be satisfied.
Do you really think Chow was run out of town? He could have stayed on as OC and asst HC. He just wanted to be HC and the AD didn't want to hire him. That happens all the time. Being OC when the HC leaves doesn't automatically qualify you to be elevated to HC. When Bronco leaves I sure hope the BYU admin looks beyond Doman for HC prospects.
Maybe Chow was afraid the new HC wouldn't want to keep him on as OC so he decided to leave earlier than necessary on his own. That turned out to be a great personal decision. He accomplished great things (truly incredible things actually) for a few years in the college ranks before hitting some stumbling blocks in the NFL.
And as far as unrealistic expectations, Chow had become so stagnant in his play-calling in his last couple years at BYU that pretty much anybody in the stands could tell you what the next play would be. I don't know what may have been going on behind the scenes -- maybe Chow felt he had little talent to work with and had no choice but to limit his playbook. But the BYU offense that everyone was used to disappeared while Chow was still at the helm.
Personally, and this is obviously just my opinion, the BYU-Chow split was great for both parties. Had Chow stayed on as HC he would have inherited the dying program that Crowton performed CPR on for several years before being declared dead. But instead, Chow got a fresh start at NC St and his play calling creativity and QB coaching genius got revived. I think leaving BYU was the best thing that happened to him. He had grown complacent at BYU it seemed and moving somewhere new forced him to prove himself again so he dug deep and struck gold.
Had Chow stayed at BYU Im afraid he would have done worse than Crowton at keeping the dying program alive. Toward the end of Lavell's tenure the recruiting plummeted. Crowton inherited the most miserable group of underclassmen skill position players imaginable. Obviously he got 1 good year with Staley and Doman, although Doman really benefited from Crowton's play calling rather than Crowton benefiting from having a gifted and talented QB (which Doman wasn't). But after that year Crowton was left with the worst WRs, RBs, QBs in the last 3 decades at BYU. Chow was lucky to be off at USC coaching some real talent while Crowton was starting freshmen at QB who were throwing to WRs who could barely run a 4.6 40 downhill.
Anyway, Chow did great stuff for BYU. Any true BYU homer will have respect for the tradition he successfully maintained after guys like Scovil built the BYU passing game. And Chow taught Detmer how to break a gazillion NCAA records and for those couple years in the stands watching the most exciting offense ever in college football up to that time I'll be forever grateful.
But I'm still glad he left BYU when he did. :)