BYU or Utah: Better Coaching Staff?

Which school has a better over all coaching staff. This poll is not simply a Bronco vs Kyle poll, but includes every coaching staff position for both schools.



BYU Coaches:



Bronco Mendenhall

Head Football Coach

Lance Reynolds

Assistant Head Coach/Tight Ends

Brandon Doman

Offensive Coordinator/Quarterbacks Coach

Ben Cahoon

Receivers Coach

Joe DuPaix

Running Backs Coach/Recruiting Coordinator

Nick Howell

Secondary/Special Teams Coach

Steve Kaufusi

Defensive Line Coach

Kelly Poppinga

Outside Linebackers Coach

Paul Tidwell

Inside Linebackers Coach

Mark Weber

Offensive Line Coach



Utah Coaches:



Kyle Whittingham

Head Coach

Kalani Fifita Sitake

Assistant Head Coach/

Defensive Coordinator/

Linebackers

Brian Johnson

Offensive Coordinator/ Quarterbacks



Dan Finn

Offensive Line

Jay Hill

Special Teams Coordinator

Running Backs

Aaron Roderick

Passing Game Coordinator

Wide Receivers

Ilaisa Tuiaki

Fullbacks/Tight Ends



Morgan Scalley

Safeties

Recruiting Coordinator

Chad Kauha'aha'a

Defensive Line

Sharrieff Shah

Cornerbacks

BYU is the better team this year. Utah takes a knock for having an extremely inexperienced offensive coordinator who has ZERO experience outside of the Utah program.

I don't really know anything about the Utah coaching staff. BYU's staff must be better because . . well, because they're BYU coaches! 8)

hawkwing wrote:
Which school has a better over all coaching staff. This poll is not simply a Bronco vs Kyle poll, but includes every coaching staff position for both schools.



BYU Coaches:



Bronco Mendenhall

Head Football Coach

Lance Reynolds

Assistant Head Coach/Tight Ends

Brandon Doman

Offensive Coordinator/Quarterbacks Coach

Ben Cahoon

Receivers Coach

Joe DuPaix

Running Backs Coach/Recruiting Coordinator

Nick Howell

Secondary/Special Teams Coach

Steve Kaufusi

Defensive Line Coach

Kelly Poppinga

Outside Linebackers Coach

Paul Tidwell

Inside Linebackers Coach

Mark Weber

Offensive Line Coach



Utah Coaches:



Kyle Whittingham

Head Coach

Kalani Fifita Sitake

Assistant Head Coach/

Defensive Coordinator/

Linebackers

Brian Johnson

Offensive Coordinator/ Quarterbacks



Dan Finn

Offensive Line

Jay Hill

Special Teams Coordinator

Running Backs

Aaron Roderick

Passing Game Coordinator

Wide Receivers

Ilaisa Tuiaki

Fullbacks/Tight Ends



Morgan Scalley

Safeties

Recruiting Coordinator

Chad Kauha'aha'a

Defensive Line

Sharrieff Shah

Cornerbacks

Head coach, I'd say is a push. Utah has a better asst head coach, OL coach (but everyone is better than Weber), DL coach, and one of their secondary coaches is probably better than ours. BYU has a better OC. Everyone else is probably a push. The way I look at it is that I would replace 3 BYU coaches with the Utah coaches right now, but only one of the BYU coaches over the same position/coordinator.



Man, that sucks to think about.

Well thank goodness youre so objective stuckin.



I may have some criticisms for Bronco occassionally, I wouldn't trade for Kryle ever. I may even take Crowtn back before that jackbutt

dmcougar wrote:
Well thank goodness youre so objective stuckin.



I may have some criticisms for Bronco occassionally, I wouldn't trade for Kryle ever. I may even take Crowtn back before that jackbutt

For BYU, I think Bronco is a much better fit, and I personally like him more. I'm just saying I'd take Sitake over Reynolds, their OL coach over Weber, and their DL coach over Kaufusi.

IowaCougar wrote:
I don't really know anything about the Utah coaching staff. BYU's staff must be better because . . well, because they're BYU coaches! 8)

Aren't all of U coaches BYU coaches or at least former BYU players? Ok not all.



Last year I would have picked U even before they out oached us and embarrassed us with a running play we were not prepared for. Someone published an article about someone not filling their lane and that the problem has been corrected. Saw that today somewhere.



This year Y. A lot of change at U. Inexperience at OC. I could even imagine some internal issues with guys pushed aside thinking "and I got pushed aside for this."



Y



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">