If they were going for ugly, they did a really good job. Besides, black is such a lame color choice and over used by everyone lately. Not exactly trend setting. Might as well stick with dark navy.
If they are going to do something like this, I hope they find a designer that understands what colors and shapes look like under non-controlled lighting on TV from 50 yards away. Some stuff looks like it was never tested or thought through.
I like the arm stripe on the undershirt in Spiff's picture. However, the compound BYU logo concept doesn't work and I never have liked the cougar with sailor cap (sorry Schmoe). It looks like a cheap cartoon from the 30's. They could come up with something much cooler for special teams, like a posterized b&w front view, full face cougar head w/fangs. You could even skeletonize it.