Archived Topic

In Defense of Bronco Mendenhall

by mcgregor · 11/6/2009

Advertisement
M
mcgregor
1. I can't blame him for this, but Bronco does not recline in easy chair and think, "How can I communicate in such a way that fans, with their limited education about what it takes to run a major D1 program, will understand what we are doing?" Rather, he more likely think, "I hate press conferences. They are for reporters that are interested in a story, even if that means stabbing me in the back to get it. They can go . . . themselves [okay, he probably doesn't think those words exactly]. I just want to get it over with, try to remember to smile once, and get back to my job."



As a result, we hear things about scheme, alignment, priorities, etc., and we have absolutely no idea what WE are talking about, evidenced by the fact that we don't really understand what HE is talking about. For instance, some fans still think we don't scheme for opponents. Or that we're not interested in bringing the absolute best athletes we can get (that will stay here).





2. Bronco has shown a remarkable ability to adapt. He's still learning. He was handed the reigns to a sick more, not a thoroughbred racehorse (unlike another HC he is often compared to). He's already tossed aside a defensive scheme he spent a career learning because it was in the best interest of the program. He's handed over play-calling. I have every reason to believe that he will continue this trend.



3. Bronco, for the first time in his career, is leading from the front. He's always been affiliated with underdog programs. He has to learn how to coach a program that is working with the best.



4. People who are complaining about not practicing enough need to understand two things: First, those same people are the ones that complained about the injuries incurred early in Bronco's HC career because he was working the kids too hard; second, Bronco's theory (backed by mounds of research) is that if you focus your efforts you can get more done in less time. Now, to this second point, it's probably not working. Hopefully this gives way to point #2 above.



5. Bronco is still young. He wasn't brought up under a great HC to mentor him. He is branding his own style and approach. He has reached a plateau, and I have every reason to believe he will learn to climb to the next level. But understand to reach the next rung, he will be teaching himself. To a large degree, it will be trial and error. This year you could say "error" if you think a 10-win season is an error. But think, once he figures this next hurdle, what will stop him from a NC?



thanks for reading, guys.



I and your employer appreciate it.



mcgregor
C
cachevalleycougar
Good points. Now he just has to go out and beat Utah. Nobody should be upset going 2-2 in "big" games on the year, but if BYU end up 1-3, fan grumbling will increase and he'll have even more crap to deal with from fan demands and media spin.

The best way for him to shut people up is to win.
F
frdbtr
the reason I gave cougarblue the finger and came to this website to post is because of posts like this. Perfectly said.
S
Sammich
Good points, I agree completely. I know less about football than probably anyone on here, but I know the difficulty of managing inter-connected variables in any complex system---and I think BYU's system is more complicated than most coaches have to deal with. And what I have learned about college football leads me to think it's a more complex system than what most CEOs have to deal with (and that is why I like college ball better than the pros). Maybe Bronco has hit a permanent plateau, but we have no way to know that, and considering his past success I think it's worth giving him several more seasons to learn and grow.



Besides, even if he has plateaued(sp?) that perfect season might be just around the corner anyway. Look at the utes last year---honestly not that great of a team, yet through fairly solid play and a bit of good fortune, they pulled out the perfect season. Both BYU and TCU were easily capable of beating them (and in TCU's case, probably should have). But none of that matters now---they won and that's all people will remember. Given the right circumstances that could be BYU, even if Bronco changed nothing. (I'm not saying it should go that way, I'm just saying even by the critic's arguments they should be more patient).
M
Mars
cachevalleycougar wrote:
Good points. Now he just has to go out and beat Ut-ah. Nobody should be upset going 2-2 in "big" games on the year, but if BYU end up 1-3, fan grumbling will increase and he'll have even more crap to deal with from fan demands and media spin. The best way for him to shut people up is to win.
Don't forget the bowl game.



As for mcgregor's 2nd point, I half-agree, half-disagree.

Bronco makes great off-season changes, and he's good over bye weeks.

Bronco and his staff usually seem to make too few mid-season and mid-game adjustments.
Advertisement
G
Guest
Thank you mcgregor, it's posts like this that make this site worth it.



I think Bronco absolutely hates press conferences and the media, and rightfully so I would say. Their desire is to create a story, and the best kinds of stories are controversial. That being said, I think he is astonishingly frank and honest with his assessments, but he definitely speaks and thinks differently than the rest of us.
B
BroncoBot
Mcg,



Totally agree. I think that Bronco just gives enough of an answer to get to the next question and the result is a lot of "coachspeak". There's much more going through that guys head than meets the eye.
4
49erCoug
hawkwing wrote:
Thank you mcgregor, it's posts like this that make this site worth it.



I think Bronco absolutely hates press conferences and the media, and rightfully so I would say. Their desire is to create a story, and the best kinds of stories are controversial.


Great post Mcgregor.. I would agree with Bronco's disdain for the media... I have always said.. The media never lets the truth get in the way of a good story!!!!
M
mcgregor
Mars wrote:
Good points. Now he just has to go out and beat Ut-ah. Nobody should be upset going 2-2 in "big" games on the year, but if BYU end up 1-3, fan grumbling will increase and he'll have even more crap to deal with from fan demands and media spin. The best way for him to shut people up is to win.
Don't forget the bowl game.



As for mcgregor's 2nd point, I half-agree, half-disagree.

Bronco makes great off-season changes, and he's good over bye weeks.

Bronco and his staff usually seem to make too few mid-season and mid-game adjustments.


The blame for lack of mid-game adjustments I place at the feet of the coordinators. Specifically, I feel that the offense has a REALLY hard time making adjustments.



Mid-season adjustments is something that needs to be talked about a little more. It's a difficult subject.
M
Metallicat
Up until this season Bronco WAS the D-coordinator. So some of that blame still goes on him, no?
Advertisement
M
Metallicat
double post
G
Guest
po_pocoug wrote:
Thank you mcgregor, it's posts like this that make this site worth it.



I think Bronco absolutely hates press conferences and the media, and rightfully so I would say. Their desire is to create a story, and the best kinds of stories are controversial.


Great post Mcgregor.. I would agree with Bronco's disdain for the media... I have always said.. The media never lets the truth get in the way of a good story!!!!


A truer statement has never been said!
M
Mars
mcgregor wrote:
As for mcgregor's 2nd point, I half-agree, half-disagree.

Bronco makes great off-season changes, and he's good over bye weeks.

Bronco and his staff usually seem to make too few mid-season and mid-game adjustments.
The blame for lack of mid-game adjustments I place at the feet of the coordinators. Specifically, I feel that the offense has a REALLY hard time making adjustments.

Mid-season adjustments is something that needs to be talked about a little more. It's a difficult subject.

I agree.
C
CougarPeasant
Great post Mcgregor, I know you and mormonrasta think alike on Bronco, that the best is yet to come once he figures out how to be a "great" coach and not just a very good one that is his now.



Good to see you btw.
C
Cougy_Monster
Mars wrote:
Mars wrote:
As for mcgregor's 2nd point, I half-agree, half-disagree.

Bronco makes great off-season changes, and he's good over bye weeks.

Bronco and his staff usually seem to make too few mid-season and mid-game adjustments.
The blame for lack of mid-game adjustments I place at the feet of the coordinators. Specifically, I feel that the offense has a REALLY hard time making adjustments.

Mid-season adjustments is something that needs to be talked about a little more. It's a difficult subject.

I agree.


I think Bronco is the greatest thing that's happened to Cougar football in a long time, but I totally agree that mid-game adjustments are lacking.



Now, I'm one of those who thought Chow was holding us back in the late 90's and I wasn't sad to see him and his delayed draws on 3rd and long leave for other opportunities, but "back in the day" even when the Cougs fell behind by 21 points at half everybody in the stands new it wasn't over because Chow was at the drawing board coming up with an entirely new gameplan for the second half. And, it usually worked.



I don't know exactly what is keeping the Cougs from adjusting at half, but when we start to get pummeled in the 1st quarter.....we all know it's already all over. We just can't adjust and come back from big deficits.



I don't think it's a permanent problem though. It'll get fixed (especially if Detmer comes on board....I can always dream).



This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.