Archived Topic

Play of the Year Happened Last Night

by cougman · 10/29/2011

Advertisement
C
cougarnerd
That's really pretty sweet. He's energetic, fiery...what a nice guy to be around. :)
B
byucougar1
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. At least he didn't slap his posterior. BYW - that play epitomizes what Riley is all about - lowers his head, goes all out, and is bound and determined to score. Gotta love the effort and reaction - a classic move destined for BYU lore.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">
S
stuckinbig10country
byucougar1 wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. At least he didn't slap his posterior. BYW - that play epitomizes what Riley is all about - lowers his head, goes all out, and is bound and determined to score. Gotta love the effort and reaction - a classic move destined for BYU lore.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">


I hope not. I thought it was pretty embarrassing to be honest. Even with that score, still down by 2 scores. (for those that think I don't like it just cause it was Nelson, you're wrong. Act like you've been there before.)
S
Schmoe
stuckinbig10country wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. At least he didn't slap his posterior. BYW - that play epitomizes what Riley is all about - lowers his head, goes all out, and is bound and determined to score. Gotta love the effort and reaction - a classic move destined for BYU lore.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">


I hope not. I thought it was pretty embarrassing to be honest. Even with that score, still down by 2 scores. (for those that think I don't like it just cause it was Nelson, you're wrong. Act like you've been there before.)


And you'd be saying the same thing if it were Heaps...or Lark... :roll:
Advertisement
S
Sammich
stuckinbig10country wrote:
I thought it was pretty embarrassing to be honest. Even with that score, still down by 2 scores. (for those that think I don't like it just cause it was Nelson, you're wrong. Act like you've been there before.)

I like Riley for doing it for the exact opposite of the reason you cited. He wasn't jumping around with his teammates like he'd just won the superbowl, he high-fived the ref clearly as a joke (the announcer thinking he mistook the ref's hands up as celebrating was also reading it wrong and no experienced football player is going to make that mistake). Riley knew they were going to lose the game and he fights for the 2 points anyway and manages to enjoy himself while doing it. That's what I'm starting to really like about him.
S
stuckinbig10country
Schmoe wrote:
byucougar1 wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. At least he didn't slap his posterior. BYW - that play epitomizes what Riley is all about - lowers his head, goes all out, and is bound and determined to score. Gotta love the effort and reaction - a classic move destined for BYU lore.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">


I hope not. I thought it was pretty embarrassing to be honest. Even with that score, still down by 2 scores. (for those that think I don't like it just cause it was Nelson, you're wrong. Act like you've been there before.)


And you'd be saying the same thing if it were Heaps...or Lark... :roll:


or JJ...or Alisa...or Bronco...or anyone....but you know what, I don't have to say that about them because they weren't stupid enough to do it.
S
stuckinbig10country
This team, while underachieving somewhat, has had some really outstanding plays this year. KVN's fumble recovery for the win against Ole Miss or his multitude of plays against UCF. Riley's heave to Jacobson against USU to set up the comeback. Riley's sweet pass to Jacobson against SJSU. Hoffman's KO return. Faslev's PR. Riley getting his helmet knocked off against OSU and still getting yardage. Even Uale's hit against Utah (even in a losing effort).



Those were all football plays.
C
Cougarbib
stuckinbig10country wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. At least he didn't slap his posterior. BYW - that play epitomizes what Riley is all about - lowers his head, goes all out, and is bound and determined to score. Gotta love the effort and reaction - a classic move destined for BYU lore.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">


I hope not. I thought it was pretty embarrassing to be honest. Even with that score, still down by 2 scores. (for those that think I don't like it just cause it was Nelson, you're wrong. Act like you've been there before.)




Hopefully someone checks whether it could draw a penalty before he does it again. If not - have fun. Play with emotion. Lossen Bronco up. Fire up the team. Did I say have fun? But if we lose a game becasue of a penalty on it - then it is stupid. Very stupid. And if it was done out of disrespect - it should not be done. If it was done being caught up in the moment and not against any rules - go for it.
M
Mars


Nelson is... human. He shows excitement, he shows frustration. Something that both Bronco and Heaps seem to have problems with in the media.



It's easy to see why Riley is liked for his on-the-field style.
Advertisement
I
IowaCougar
I loved it! It looked totally spontaneous, and I really think he just saw the hands up and high-fived without realizing it was the ref until afterward. He was just celebrating a very difficult, successful effort. And at the time, the Cougars were still holding out some hope.



Loosen up guys - this is sports, not life and death! Have fun!
J
jonnylingo
byucougar1 wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. g[/img]


i will disagree with that. he was clearly down before the ball got in. not that anybody cares. the game was over.
B
byucougar1
ESPN announcers loved it, had fun with it and saw it as contagious enthusiasm, and replayed the scene several times. Bronco didn't comment about it - and face it, it was a fantastic play and effort - rare to see a QB lowering his head and shoulders and taking on DBs. We loved it at the game - were surprised by it but thought it was great and fired us up. The play is pure Riley and shows how fiery he is as a leader and the emotion he brings to the game.



[ Post made via Mobile Device ] http://cougarcorner.com/images/mobile.png" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">
I
IowaCougar
jonnylingo wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. g[/img]


i will disagree with that. he was clearly down before the ball got in. not that anybody cares. the game was over.




Wrong - they showed several replays that proved that he got in before going down. More negativity!
J
jonnylingo
IowaCougar wrote:
byucougar1 wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. g[/img]


i will disagree with that. he was clearly down before the ball got in. not that anybody cares. the game was over.




Wrong - they showed several replays that proved that he got in before going down. More negativity!


I watched the replay and it looked to me like his knee was down. Go look at the youtube clip. it is frozen with his knee down and the ball clearly short of the endzone. Sorry for pointing that out. "More negativity!!" Are you serious?
Advertisement
S
Sammich
jonnylingo wrote:
jonnylingo wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. g[/img]


i will disagree with that. he was clearly down before the ball got in. not that anybody cares. the game was over.




Wrong - they showed several replays that proved that he got in before going down. More negativity!


I watched the replay and it looked to me like his knee was down. Go look at the youtube clip. it is frozen with his knee down and the ball clearly short of the endzone. Sorry for pointing that out. "More negativity!!" Are you serious?

Wrong.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-8VGzn22V3JU/Tq7IGhb-jCI/AAAAAAAAB9w/_VPVp5WlsAw/s1024/NelsonKnee.jpg" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">

Back knee was moving smoothly in the video, no impact or shadow to show that it was clearly down. Whether the refs made the right call I don't know, but there is not enough evidence in the replay to say he was down.
J
jonnylingo
Sammich wrote:
IowaCougar wrote:
byucougar1 wrote:
He's complimenting the ref on one of the few plays called correctly. g[/img]


i will disagree with that. he was clearly down before the ball got in. not that anybody cares. the game was over.




Wrong - they showed several replays that proved that he got in before going down. More negativity!


I watched the replay and it looked to me like his knee was down. Go look at the youtube clip. it is frozen with his knee down and the ball clearly short of the endzone. Sorry for pointing that out. "More negativity!!" Are you serious?

Wrong.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-8VGzn22V3JU/Tq7IGhb-jCI/AAAAAAAAB9w/_VPVp5WlsAw/s1024/NelsonKnee.jpg" alt="" loading="lazy" style="max-width:100%">

Back knee was moving smoothly in the video, no impact or shadow to show that it was clearly down. Whether the refs made the right call I don't know, but there is not enough evidence in the replay to say he was down.


I think you made my point. In my opinion it is clear that he is down. however there is apparently some evidence that he is not. that is different than mr. negativity's claim that replays 'proved' he was not down.
S
SpoCoug
I thought he was down. And while that picture may be unclear, how likely is it that he sailed for another foot and a half with neither knee touching the ground?
B
byufan4ever
IowaCougar wrote:
I loved it! It looked totally spontaneous, and I really think he just saw the hands up and high-fived without realizing it was the ref until afterward. He was just celebrating a very difficult, successful effort. And at the time, the Cougars were still holding out some hope.



Loosen up guys - this is sports, not life and death! Have fun!


+1



It was funny and my wife and I both laughed and watched it about a dozen times. Does college football need to turn into the No Fun League as well? One thing our team has lacked in past years has been emotion. I loved it. Have some fun!!
R
redneckjedi
First of all, that angle wasn't the best one to see it - it was the reverse, low angle that was the best on this play. Second, it was pretty clear to me from that particular angle that neither knee touches before the ball does, and the ball touches the ground across the plane of the goal line. Third, trying to prove a point like this with a still is retarded. When you actually play the video, you can clearly see the ball cross the plane just before 0:14, and you can see that the legs are still moving at that point, and that their motion changes due to impact with the ground after 0:14. Fourth, talking about likelihood is equally stupid for an event that has already happened. Is it likely that he went that far without touching the ground? Perhaps not, but he did it, so likelihood is irrelevant. Fifth, the ref on the play made the right call. The guys in the booth upheld it. All evidence we have at our disposal upholds both of their decisions. And ignoring that evidence does not make anybody more "objective" or "realistic" a fan than accepting it does.



Case closed.



P.S. I hate it when people go against their own team to try to appear objective.
Page 1 of 2
This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.