fact is, good teams don't need a second shot. And even if we got one, I doubt the result would be very different. For BYU to beat a good team (not the drivel we play 90% of our games against), we have to play a complete game. Between inconsistent coaching, dumb turnovers, special teams gaffs, occasional massive defensive let downs, etc., BYU just has too much inconsistency to play a complete game against a good team. If it isn't one thing, it is another.
Consistent clutch defensive stops but offensive miscues and anemic play
Offensive consistency and progression with defensive and spec. teams let downs.
You may only choose one.