M
MarsWest Virginia:
2011 partial- 5-2 #33
2010- 9-4 #41
2009- 9-4 #26
2008- 9-4 #25
2007- 11-2 #5
2006- 11-2 #10
Total: 54-18, Average: #23.3
BYU:
2011 partial- 6-2 #55
2010- 7-6 #44
2009- 11-2 #9
2008- 10-3 #34
2007- 11-2 #15
2006- 11-2 #20
Total: 56-17, Average: #29.5
Cincinnati:
2011 partial- 6-1 #41
2010- 4-8 #71
2009- 12-1 #5
2008- 11-3 #19
2007- 10-3 #23
2006- 8-5 #28
Total: 51-21, Average: #31.6
Louisville:
2011 partial- 3-4 #88
2010- 7-6 #60
2009- 4-8 #78
2008- 5-7 #74
2007- 6-6 #50
2006- 12-1 #6
Total: 37-32, Average: #59.3
All 3 have had arguably a single season better than our best over the past 5 1/2 years, including BCS bowls, but only West Virginia has had a consistently equal-or-better program.
Combined with men's basketball, taking Cincy over BYU doesn't make much sense. The other two schools have their definite talking points. WVU probably beats out BYU in both major sports, though not by a large amount.
And our football stadium/attendance and basketball arena beat all 6 those guys offer.
TV Market- Number of television sets? Academic research dollars spent per year? Least/most/average miles to the school from the Big XII? I don't have those numbers right now.