Time for a new offensive coordinator

Anae is solid, not great. To get to the big stage I think it'll take a new offensive coordinator. BYU is good. We could finish with a respectable 10 win season still, but to get to a BCS bowl I think a shake up is in order. What we have right now isn't working as far as getting to a BCS bowl.

And what do you think about a D that has started to make every QB they play look like the Heisman front runner?

BYU Christmas list



1. Improved Defense

2. Smarter Offense (I'm not bagging on Anae, just think that there is room for improvement in terms of decisions)

declocoug wrote:
BYU Christmas list



1. Improved Defense

2. Smarter Offense (I'm not bagging on Anae, just think that there is room for improvement in terms of decisions)

Defense is getting there. There is marked improvement in the defense this year. Whereas the decision making of the offense hasn't gotten better.



Anae has been at the helm a number of seasons now with limited improvement. This is Hill's first real season guiding the defense.

Gunk wrote:

BYU Christmas list



1. Improved Defense

2. Smarter Offense (I'm not bagging on Anae, just think that there is room for improvement in terms of decisions)

Defense is getting there. There is marked improvement in the defense this year. Whereas the decision making of the offense hasn't gotten better.



Anae has been at the helm a number of seasons now with limited improvement. This is Hill's first real season guiding the defense.

Agree completely about the defense. But after tonight I don't know if I would call our defense "markedly improved". I think we all bought into hype, letting a TCU team score 38+ is embarrassing. I'd say it made a baby step this year.



Offense, I can't tell if it's Anae, or the QB deciding to throw 30 yarders instead of 6 for the first down. Probably a little of both.

declocoug wrote:

declocoug wrote:
BYU Christmas list



1. Improved Defense

2. Smarter Offense (I'm not bagging on Anae, just think that there is room for improvement in terms of decisions)

Defense is getting there. There is marked improvement in the defense this year. Whereas the decision making of the offense hasn't gotten better.



Anae has been at the helm a number of seasons now with limited improvement. This is Hill's first real season guiding the defense.

Agree completely about the defense. But after tonight I don't know if I would call our defense "markedly improved". I think we all bought into hype, letting a TCU team score 38+ is embarrassing. I'd say it made a baby step this year.



Offense, I can't tell if it's Anae, or the QB deciding to throw 30 yarders instead of 6 for the first down. Probably a little of both.

Either way, blame falls on Anae because he relinquishes a significant portion of the play calling to college kids. He's supposed to be the expert.

Hard to argue with that Gunk.

Gunk wrote:
Anae is solid, not great. To get to the big stage I think it'll take a new offensive coordinator. BYU is good. We could finish with a respectable 10 win season still, but to get to a BCS bowl I think a shake up is in order. What we have right now isn't working as far as getting to a BCS bowl.

I agree with every jot and tittle.

Alright, let's say Anae "moves on". What kind of offensive coord. would suit BYU the best? What style of play is going to play to BYU's strengths and minimize weaknesses?



I don't really have any answers, just would like to know how the system could be improved?

declocoug wrote:
Alright, let's say Anae "moves on". What kind of offensive coord. would suit BYU the best? What style of play is going to play to BYU's strengths and minimize weaknesses?



I don't really have any answers, just would like to know how the system could be improved?

Anae is 90% great. But he's tapped out. He sometimes get bogged down in games, and fails to see the big picture. We hoped that would change by placing him in the booth. It hasn't.



Someone replacing him would be a near-clone, but someone that made better in-game decisions, and was able to dissect the defense a little better.

declocoug wrote:
Alright, let's say Anae "moves on". What kind of offensive coord. would suit BYU the best? What style of play is going to play to BYU's strengths and minimize weaknesses?



I don't really have any answers, just would like to know how the system could be improved?

Not too sure about this either. I think you hit on the biggest weakness earlier, and that's the decision making capabilities. I don't think it's so much we need a new offensive system or something. I think we need an OC that can make better calls. We have great QBs and receiving corp, but for some reason we have a hard time putting it all together.

McG and Gunk, I agree that Anae (and the offense) is great most of the time, especially when they have a lead. But they seem to !STRUGGLE! when they get down, especially by more than one score. Patience seems to be a virtue that these Cougars simply do not have. Again, I'm not knowledgeable enough to know where exactly the problem lies. Anae's play calling, Hall's choices at the line and in the moment. There seems to be ample talent and BYU should be able to score more than 7 points vs TCU. There are some hidden (to me anyway) wrinkles that need ironed out somewhere. I'm not sure it it's all just Anae's play calling but I suspect it could be a large part of the issue.



I do know that it all frustrates the dickens out of me.

I agree that something needs to happen. Tonight on a 3rd and 8 I leaned over to my buddy and said "If we run a draw I am going to lose my mind." We run a draw and I lost my mind.

Anae is predictable and the MWC has him figured out. I don't know if I'm saying that he needs to be fired, maybe I am, but there needs to be some serious changes going on in the offensive gameplan.

mcgregor wrote:

Alright, let's say Anae "moves on". What kind of offensive coord. would suit BYU the best? What style of play is going to play to BYU's strengths and minimize weaknesses?



I don't really have any answers, just would like to know how the system could be improved?

Anae is 90% great. But he's tapped out. He sometimes get bogged down in games, and fails to see the big picture. We hoped that would change by placing him in the booth. It hasn't.



Someone replacing him would be a near-clone, but someone that made better in-game decisions, and was able to dissect the defense a little better.

I like what you are saying, I'm wondering are there any names out there that are potential candidates? Is Domon ready for a shot? Do we take a OC from someone else? Is a weaker team HC ready for a chance to be OC at a bigger school? I'm not sure who is out there that may be a good fit.

Perhaps Crowton will be available soon??? :lol:

My main problem is with the defensive coaching... until that changes, it doesn't matter what we do on offense. It still strikes me as funny that the DB coach is the one that gets the promo to DC. Our D-backs have routinely been the worst part of our defense... I like Bronco's approach to recruiting (see: Miracle) and his personnel ability (his players "buy in" every single year), but I would like to see more fire from him as far as bad calls go, and also more passion about the lack of coaching going on...



We have good players on both sides of the ball.

I'm afraid that there is no way in the world that Anae will get fired. His record is too good. The problem is that we play in the MWC where more then half of the teams are mediocre at best so a good record here isn't saying much. My problem is that TCU and Utah have us figured out. Anae is predictable and it drives me nuts.

CannonCougar85 wrote:
I'm afraid that there is no way in the world that Anae will get fired. His record is too good. The problem is that we play in the MWC where more then half of the teams are mediocre at best so a good record here isn't saying much. My problem is that TCU and Utah have us figured out. Anae is predictable and it drives me nuts.

But we've always played against this kind of competition, in the MWC and before that in the WAC, and we've never had the consistent success that we've had the last several years. I agree that something needs to change for us to move to that elite level, but I don't think it's as simple as just changing a coordinator.

Schmoe wrote:

I'm afraid that there is no way in the world that Anae will get fired. His record is too good. The problem is that we play in the MWC where more then half of the teams are mediocre at best so a good record here isn't saying much. My problem is that TCU and Utah have us figured out. Anae is predictable and it drives me nuts.

But we've always played against this kind of competition, in the MWC and before that in the WAC, and we've never had the consistent success that we've had the last several years. I agree that something needs to change for us to move to that elite level, but I don't think it's as simple as just changing a coordinator.

Changing a coordinator certainly won't change things completely. I think we can all agree more speed is needed on the team, especially on the defensive end, and more athleticism. But just picking up a talented player here and there isn't going to change things drastically. It will take a higher level of talent across the board on both sides of the ball, which will take a long time and is partly dependent on how well we do. With Utah going to a BCS bowl two times in the last 5 years and TCU headed there as well BYU will start to lose MWC recruits. If we lose to Utah this year, that's two years in a row we would have lost to both TCU and Utah, establishing BYU as the present day third best team in the MWC. A dangerous position to be in, especially with Utah competing directly with many of our recruits.



Switching the OC won't change things over night, but it might slow the bleeding a bit and get us someone who's a bit better at squeezing as much juice out of what he's given.