He's put 5 WRs into the NFL as a WR coach and one quarterback (Travis Wilson) as a QB coach.Roderick had been coaching at the college level for seven years. he's now coached for more than ten. We've seen his ceiling. It ain't much.Roderick was a QB coach only in 2014. The other two seasons he was Co-Offensive Coordinator in addition to QB coach, so what does that mean to your analysis?You're using Detmer's numbers as an OC to compare with Roderick. Detmer was never just a QB coach - I'd have been more excited to have seen him given a go as that and focus on just the QB than I am to see someone who has shown what his word is worth and has been proven to be worthy of firing
And FWIW, Ty also showed he was worthy of firing.....so they're even on that score, aren't they?
Again-- based on what do you think Detmer is better at coaching college QBs that Roderick?
Roderick was fired for his performance as Co-OC, not QB coach -- his QBs performed better in the year before he was fired than they did the year he got promoted from QB coach to Co-OC.BYU is replacing it's incompetent OC / QB coach with a QB coach who was fired from his last job for being an incompetent OC/QB coach.
Statistics: Posted by canadiancoug24 — Tue Jan 02, 2018 11:36 pm
Statistics: Posted by Ddawg — Tue Jan 02, 2018 10:54 pm
Statistics: Posted by a1247 — Tue Jan 02, 2018 10:14 pm
He's put 5 WRs into the NFL as a WR coach and one quarterback (Travis Wilson) as a QB coach.Roderick had been coaching at the college level for seven years. he's now coached for more than ten. We've seen his ceiling. It ain't much.Roderick was a QB coach only in 2014. The other two seasons he was Co-Offensive Coordinator in addition to QB coach, so what does that mean to your analysis?You're using Detmer's numbers as an OC to compare with Roderick. Detmer was never just a QB coach - I'd have been more excited to have seen him given a go as that and focus on just the QB than I am to see someone who has shown what his word is worth and has been proven to be worthy of firing
And FWIW, Ty also showed he was worthy of firing.....so they're even on that score, aren't they?
Again-- based on what do you think Detmer is better at coaching college QBs that Roderick?
Roderick was fired for his performance as Co-OC, not QB coach -- his QBs performed better in the year before he was fired than they did the year he got promoted from QB coach to Co-OC.BYU is replacing it's incompetent OC / QB coach with a QB coach who was fired from his last job for being an incompetent OC/QB coach.
Statistics: Posted by a1247 — Tue Jan 02, 2018 8:10 pm
Roderick had been coaching at the college level for seven years. he's now coached for more than ten. We've seen his ceiling. It ain't much.Roderick was a QB coach only in 2014. The other two seasons he was Co-Offensive Coordinator in addition to QB coach, so what does that mean to your analysis?You're using Detmer's numbers as an OC to compare with Roderick. Detmer was never just a QB coach - I'd have been more excited to have seen him given a go as that and focus on just the QB than I am to see someone who has shown what his word is worth and has been proven to be worthy of firing
And FWIW, Ty also showed he was worthy of firing.....so they're even on that score, aren't they?
Again-- based on what do you think Detmer is better at coaching college QBs that Roderick?
Roderick was fired for his performance as Co-OC, not QB coach -- his QBs performed better in the year before he was fired than they did the year he got promoted from QB coach to Co-OC.BYU is replacing it's incompetent OC / QB coach with a QB coach who was fired from his last job for being an incompetent OC/QB coach.
Statistics: Posted by snoscythe — Tue Jan 02, 2018 4:35 pm
And an evaluation, at least, of the AD.And by fire them all, you mean the entire coaching staff, correct? Offense. Defense. Head Coach. Strength & Conditioning. Football Operations.I'm giving them a year. If we see good results, I give them another. If we have another losing season, fire them all.
I want a complete overhaul of the football program if we fail to make a bowl game in 2018.
Statistics: Posted by ABYUFAN — Tue Jan 02, 2018 3:16 pm
And by fire them all, you mean the entire coaching staff, correct? Offense. Defense. Head Coach. Strength & Conditioning. Football Operations.I'm giving them a year. If we see good results, I give them another. If we have another losing season, fire them all.
Statistics: Posted by frdbtr — Tue Jan 02, 2018 2:24 pm
Roderick was a QB coach only in 2014. The other two seasons he was Co-Offensive Coordinator in addition to QB coach, so what does that mean to your analysis?You're using Detmer's numbers as an OC to compare with Roderick. Detmer was never just a QB coach - I'd have been more excited to have seen him given a go as that and focus on just the QB than I am to see someone who has shown what his word is worth and has been proven to be worthy of firing
Statistics: Posted by ABYUFAN — Tue Jan 02, 2018 2:04 pm